A small marketing team can buy a creator platform and still end up running every partnership itself. These tools help your team find creators and keep track of partnerships, but your team still does most of the work. Someone needs to choose creators, handle replies, negotiate the terms, and make sure the content gets made.
Before choosing a provider, think about where you need help. You may have an experienced team that wants better tools, need someone to run the partnerships, or want help figuring out which messages and creators will work. Those needs often overlap, so it’s worth looking at the advice a provider can give you alongside the work it takes off your plate.
Automation can help you run more partnerships, but you still need to choose the right creators, develop effective messaging, and learn from the results. 1stCollab combines both: our creator intelligence and proprietary partnership data help shape the strategy, while our automation runs the partnerships and tracks performance so we can keep improving the brief and targeting. As you compare providers, look for how they help you get better results as well as reduce the work involved.
Start with what your team needs help doing
Suppose you want to find out which uses of your product resonate with potential customers. You could test different messages with several groups of relevant smaller creators. To learn from that, you’ll need to choose creators who can tell each story well, get the partnerships running, and compare the results. Finding names is only the beginning.
Tools can make each task easier, but your team may still need to manage the campaign from start to finish. That can work well if someone already runs your program and needs better software. If nobody has time to run it, you’ll need a provider that takes on the work for you.
Taking on the execution is valuable, but so is helping you decide what to run. Ask how the provider would choose creators for each message and what it would recommend once the results arrive. You want to come away knowing more about what works for your product, with a clear idea of what to try next.
You can steer the creative direction without handling every conversation yourself. If you’re deciding which responsibilities to keep on your team, our agency, platform, and in-house guide walks through what you’d manage under each approach.
Look beyond the AI label
That’s also how we’d evaluate a provider’s AI. A search assistant or email generator can save time, but look at whether it helps make the campaign more effective too. Can it explain why a creator fits, suggest messages worth testing, and recommend changes based on performance? Ask what data supports those recommendations, including what the provider knows about creators and how previous partnerships performed.
For example, what happens when a creator proposes a higher price or a different format? Does the system help assess the proposal and handle the negotiation, or does it leave a message for your team to resolve? When some posts perform better than others, does it help you improve the brief and targeting, or simply present another report?
Ask providers to demonstrate how they’d handle those situations. Modash documents email automation, Collabstr offers AI-assisted briefs and matching, and GRIN positions Gia around campaign execution. Seeing those features applied to your campaign helps you understand what they handle and where your team would be involved.
Build a shortlist around the support you need
With those needs in mind, you can narrow the options. The table below explains when we’d consider each provider and what we’d ask about its recommendations, execution, and costs before signing up.
Option | When we’d consider it | Work and costs to clarify |
|---|---|---|
You want creator intelligence to help develop and test the strategy, with the partnerships run for you and results improving the next campaign | How our recommendations fit your product, what you want to test, where you want to stay involved, and the full budget | |
You want to run the partnerships yourself, with a more organized way to find creators, manage conversations, and track results | Who handles replies, negotiations, and production follow-up after an automated email sends | |
You want to choose and hire creators yourself, with a marketplace to organize proposals, purchases, and payments | Who evaluates proposals, agrees on scope and price, and manages changes, plus plan and hiring fees | |
You want to start with its creator database and campaign tools, with the option to pay for Amplify support | What Zest handles, how recruiting outside the platform works, the data behind recommendations, and any extra support costs | |
You plan to run a paid, gifting, affiliate, or UGC program and want to test whether Gia can reduce the work your team handles | Have Gia work through a real reply, counteroffer, and changed brief. Check what it completes and what your team still has to do | |
Aspire | You want to run an ecommerce creator program with more organized workflows, or separately buy services to take on the execution | Whether you’re buying tools to operate or a team to run the work, and what each arrangement costs |
Upfluence | You want to run creator and affiliate partnerships yourself, with ecommerce, outreach, and payments organized together | What its AI and automation execute, who handles unresolved conversations, and the store and payment setup |
CreatorIQ | You have teams to run the program and need a more organized way to coordinate creator work, measurement, and approvals across them | Who operates the program, what implementation involves, and which execution work remains with your team |
Our comparisons with Modash, Collabstr, Passionfroot, and GRIN work through those choices in more detail. Each follows a campaign beyond finding creators so you can assess the responsibilities you’d retain.
See how 1stCollab combines strategy and execution
Framer already had a creator direction it wanted to grow, but conversations, contracts, and reporting were scattered across tools. We brought that information together and automated recurring work around negotiations, contracts, and payments. Its team could spend more time on strategy and creator engagement as the program expanded. Our Framer case study explains the transition.
Gamma needed to learn which creator audiences to develop, as well as find a way to run the partnerships. We helped it test different audiences and briefs, tracked performance, and used the results to refine targeting. On Lenny’s Podcast, co-founder Grant Lee described how we found creators around profiles such as educators and automated outreach. In our customer story, he reported spending less than an hour a week managing the program. Our Gamma case study explains how the team kept learning and expanding without building an internal influencer team.
Both teams kept control over their direction while we helped them grow. You can do the same: choose creators and guide the content yourself, follow our recommendations, or delegate more to us. Staying involved in those decisions doesn’t mean you have to handle every reply and negotiation.
Follow one campaign through the actual work
Give the finalists the same campaign and ask them to show how they’d find a suitable creator, agree on the partnership, and get the content live. Then introduce a realistic change: a counteroffer, an access problem, or a request to use the content in ads. Keep track of what the product handles, what a service team handles, and what comes back to you.
Follow the campaign into reporting too. For an app, for example, check how you’d track activations or subscriptions and use those results to improve the brief and creator targeting. Apply that test to 1stCollab as well as the other finalists, so you can see how each would help you run and improve the campaign.
Compare the full cost and get started
Once you’ve narrowed the options, compare what it would cost to run the same campaign with each provider. Creator fees are only part of that total. Include software subscriptions, service and payment fees, tax administration, and the time your team would spend running the campaign. If you’d need to hire someone as the program grows, include that too. Our budget guide walks through the costs to account for, including sending products to creators, buying usage rights, and promoting content through paid ads when those are part of your plan.
1stCollab makes that calculation simpler. Our Fully Managed fee is a flat 20% of creator spend, covering our AI and campaign software, execution, creator payments, and tax-filing administration. You get those services together, without separate software subscriptions or transaction fees, and can grow the program without hiring someone to manage every additional partnership. The plan has a minimum $5,000 monthly campaign spend.
Whether you already know what you want to run or need help figuring it out, we can help develop the strategy and put it into practice. Bring your ideas, and our AI can help you build a complete campaign in minutes. Planning is free, and you only pay when you launch. Sign up for free to get started, or schedule a free consultation with our team to talk through your goals and how we can help.