Choosing a marketing channel is difficult when you’re being asked to commit money before you know how well it will work for your product. Search, paid social, and creator partnerships can all help you reach customers, but they do different jobs and ask different things of your team.
Influencer marketing becomes worth considering when a relevant person can show people something useful about your product. That could be a familiar problem it solves, a routine it improves or a task that becomes easier to complete. Before paying to reach a wider audience, though, you need confidence that the experience is ready for someone to recommend.
In this guide, we’ll work through that decision: where creator marketing might fit alongside your other channels, how product maturity affects readiness, and what you need to run a worthwhile first test. By the end, you should know whether to start planning a campaign or which preparation would make it a better investment later. If you’re ready to start, our first-campaign guide helps you turn that decision into a realistic plan.
Decide what you want influencer marketing to accomplish
Before choosing a channel, look at where you’re losing potential customers. Some may not know your product exists, while others have heard of it but don’t understand why they’d use it. Knowing which problem you’re trying to solve helps you decide whether you need to reach people already looking for a solution or give them a reason to consider one.
If people already search for the problem your product solves, search marketing can help them find you. Google’s SEO and PPC explanation describes the organic and paid ways to appear in those searches. But someone who would benefit from your product may not be looking for it yet. A creator can introduce it through a situation they already care about. For a scheduling app, that could mean showing how to manage an irregular working week, giving viewers a reason to consider the app before they ever search for another calendar tool.
Once you have an explanation that works, paid social can help you put it in front of more people. If you already have strong creative, that may be a better next investment than producing more content. If you still need someone to make the product’s value clear, a creator partnership can help develop that story. The two can work together too: you might sponsor a creator’s post, then pay to distribute the content more widely. Our creator marketing and paid social guide explains how to think about those investments together.
There’s one more thing to check before investing in that reach: what happens when someone is interested? If they struggle to try or buy the product, bringing more people to it won’t fix the problem. Before asking creators to recommend it, make sure the experience delivers what you want them to promise.
Check whether the product is ready to be recommended
Before paying to bring more people to the product, try it as a new user. Can someone get the benefit you want to promote without your team walking them through every step? Would a relevant creator be excited to recommend that experience? If either answer is no, improve it before launching a campaign around it.
Your product doesn’t need to be perfect before you promote it. It needs a dependable experience for the particular use case being promoted. If the core workflow is still unreliable or the team is unsure who it serves, a broad creator campaign may amplify confusion while providing little help with the underlying product question.
Consider a fictional scheduling app. Its calendar interface might look appealing on video, but if new users cannot connect their accounts, the campaign is not ready to promise an easy weekly routine. Fix that journey and try it with representative users before paying creators to send more people through it.
You can still talk to creators while developing the product. They may help you understand what people find useful or confusing. Just be clear about the goal: getting feedback on an early product is different from paying creators to recommend an experience you’re ready to sell.
Find a story worth sharing
Once the product experience is ready, turn its benefit into a situation someone would recognize. What is the person trying to do, what gets in their way, and how does the product help? That gives the creator a story to develop rather than leaving them to find a reason to mention the product.
For the scheduling app, a creator could show how they organize a week around irregular shifts, giving viewers a situation they recognize and a reason to consider the product. Start there. An instruction to mention calendar features leaves the creator with much more work to do to make the story interesting.
SnapCalorie needed health and fitness creators who could introduce its calorie-tracking app, so we sourced relevant people, coordinated content review, and tracked results through to attributed subscriptions. Gradient AI needed a more technical explanation. We found creators working in AI software engineering, machine learning, and data science and ran partnerships around dedicated YouTube demonstrations. The SnapCalorie and Gradient AI case studies show how the creator choice followed the product story. For your own readiness decision, ask whether you can identify something worth explaining and people equipped to explain it.
If the only content idea is a list of promotional claims, develop the explanation further before building a roster. The creator should have something useful to communicate beyond the fact that the brand is paying for a mention.
Check that relevant creators can tell that story
With that story in mind, look for people whose existing content already covers the task, routine, or problem. Their work lets you assess both subject fit and how they explain it. You need a plausible group of relevant creators before you can turn a good idea into a realistic campaign.
Profile categories can give you a place to start, but the creator’s actual posts and the questions in the comments will tell you more about whether your product fits the content. The shortlist should contain people who have a credible reason to make your particular demonstration.
If the first search produces too few suitable creators, try different use cases and targeting before deciding the audience is too narrow. Your buyers may follow teachers, coaches, practitioners, or other creators outside your product category. Look for enough relevant people to test several approaches. If the product still has no credible creator audience or isn’t ready to use, address that before funding the campaign.
If you have a starting idea but aren’t sure how to find people who could make it well, our guide to finding creators shows how to turn the use case into a relevant search.
Make sure the campaign fits the budget and bandwidth
Work out what your team needs to contribute alongside the budget. Creators need access to the product and someone who can answer their questions. If your team wants to review content before it goes live, make sure someone has time to provide feedback. You can automate or delegate much of the campaign, but make sure the work your team wants to retain fits its bandwidth.
Decide who will answer product questions and review any claims you want to check before publication. Even a well-matched creator can get stuck waiting for access or feedback. Make sure someone has time for those tasks before expanding the roster.
If you’re unsure what the campaign would cost, our budget guide helps you add creator fees and the costs of running it. Work out whether that budget gives you enough relevant posts to test different briefs and creator audiences. That will tell you more than pricing a handful of partnerships in isolation.
Plan a first test you can learn from
If the product is ready, plan a campaign that tests different messages and creator audiences. Favor many relevant smaller creators so the budget produces enough posts to learn from, rather than relying on a few big partnerships. Decide what you’ll measure for each approach and use those results to improve the brief, targeting, and next investment.
Test the tracking before publication and note anything it can’t capture. A visit, activation, purchase, and qualified inquiry tell you different things, so choose the result that matters for this campaign. You can learn whether people understand and try the product before you have enough customers to judge the longer-term acquisition cost.
If you’ve found a product story worth exploring, our campaign planning guide helps turn it into a brief, budget, and plan for reaching the right people. You can also work through the idea with 1stCollab’s AI and develop an entire campaign in minutes, whether you already know the direction or need help finding it. We’ll run the partnerships when you launch, with as much involvement from your team as you want. Planning is free, and you only pay when you launch. Sign up for free to get started, or schedule a free consultation with our team to discuss whether influencer marketing makes sense for your product.