When you’re planning an influencer campaign, one of the first decisions is which kinds of creators to work with. Should you put the budget behind a few people with large followings, or spread it across a larger group of smaller creators? Both can introduce your product to potential customers, but they give you different ways to use the same budget.
A larger creator may offer a particular audience, expertise, or style of content you want. Smaller partnerships can leave room to try more creators and more ways of explaining the product, though there are also more partnerships to run. The choice needs to account for what you want people to understand, what the creators would make, and what you could afford to test.
For most campaigns, we recommend starting with many relevant smaller creators. Individual posts can perform very differently, even within the same creator’s campaign. More partnerships give you more opportunities to try different briefs and creator audiences, learn what works, and build on the promising combinations. A larger creator can still be worth including when they bring something specific the campaign needs.
We’ll use our pricing and performance research to work through when a larger creator could be worth the fee and when to spread the budget across more smaller partnerships. Then we’ll look at the creators, quotes, and work involved in your own campaign.
Evaluate the audience and explanation first
Start with what you want people to understand about your product, then look for creators who already explain that kind of problem. For a developer tool, that might mean practitioners who walk through implementations. Their recent posts can show whether they understand the use case and can make it clear to the customers you want to reach.
You may find several smaller creators who can do that well, each with a different way of explaining the product. Working with a broader group gives you room to try those approaches and see which explanations resonate with different audiences. That’s where we’d usually start, with enough relevant creators to give each promising idea a fair chance.
As you review candidates, a larger creator may stand out for a particularly relevant audience or a style of explanation you want. Compare what that person would add with what the same budget could fund across the smaller group. If you include the larger creator, leave enough budget to keep testing other people and messages too.
Save the posts that show why each creator fits and review them alongside the quotes. You’ll have concrete examples of what the campaign could look like, making it easier to decide whether a larger partnership is worth the price or the budget would go further across a larger group of smaller creators.
What the pricing and performance research tells us
The price gap can make room for far more partnerships with smaller creators. Our 2025 asking-price report found a $300 median ask for a video among creators below 10,000 followers or subscribers, compared with $7,000 at one million or more. Those lower fees let you spread the budget across more relevant creators and try different messages instead of depending on a few expensive posts.
Our portfolio report explains the case for spreading a budget across more lower-cost posts. More relevant attempts create more opportunities for a standout, while the results help you decide which briefs and creator groups to develop. The extra partnerships take work, which is why automation is central to making this strategy practical.
Our analysis of tracked campaign views found that a small share of posts could contribute much of a campaign’s distribution. Look beyond the total. Whichever follower sizes you choose, review the ordinary partnerships alongside the standouts so you know how much of the result depended on unusually strong posts.
Compare the full cost of each roster
Compare the campaigns you could run with the same budget. If you work with more creators, account for the time and support needed to get their content live.
List the actual candidates, formats, deliverables, and compensation. Add rights, management, and the internal work needed to find creators, agree on terms, review content, and pay creators.
Plan how you’ll support that volume instead of choosing an expensive, narrow roster simply because it seems easier to manage. Automate outreach and negotiations, give creators clear briefs, and decide which reviews your team needs to keep. If feedback is slowing the program down, simplify the review process or get help with it so more relevant content can go live.
For the higher-priced option, explain what you would be paying more for: a relevant audience, specialist expertise, better production, or another part of the agreed work. Then compare it with what the same budget could buy elsewhere, using our creator valuation guide to weigh the fee against the package.
Decide what each creator brings to the campaign
If you combine a specialist walkthrough with shorter posts from other creators, set out what you want each part to achieve. The walkthrough may help buyers evaluate implementation, while the shorter posts introduce use cases to different audiences. Write the briefs around those different goals, and decide how you’ll measure each one.
For the walkthrough, you might look at whether interested people try the implementation or start an evaluation. For the introductions, you might compare which messages bring relevant people to the product. If you also bought content for your own channels, assess that use separately from the creator’s organic distribution.
Use those results to decide which parts to repeat. The campaign total still matters, but it won’t tell you whether the specialist explanation did its job or which shorter briefs are worth developing.
Build a roster around the work you need
Put the final candidates, briefs, quotes, and planned results together. Can you explain what each creator adds and still fund enough relevant posts to test different messages and audiences? If not, adjust the creator list or deliverables until you have a campaign that fits the budget and gives you enough posts to learn from.
Our roster-sizing guide helps connect those choices with the full budget and the production and review work needed to get the content live.
1stCollab uses what we know about creators and past partnerships to help choose people suited to your product, rather than relying on follower counts alone. We’ll run the partnerships and help you build on what works, with as much involvement from your team as you want. Our AI can help develop the full campaign in minutes. Planning is free, and you only pay when you launch. Sign up for free to get started, or schedule a free consultation with our team to discuss the creator mix that could suit your goals and budget.